Maryland's drive-in carry exception leaves Sabbath walkers exposed, lawsuit says
A Maryland gun law meant to regulate carry near houses of worship has produced an odd result: Orthodox Jews who can't drive on Shabbat are effectively barred from carrying a firearm to synagogue, even though the same law lets them carry once they're inside.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms reports on a Montgomery County carry rule, upheld by a judge's September ruling, that lets licensed gun owners drive within 100 yards of a place of worship while armed but fines anyone who walks that distance carrying. At the Silver Spring Jewish Center, where Rabbi Menashe Shapiro serves as one of several armed volunteer congregants providing security, that distinction collides directly with Jewish religious practice.
Key points
- The rule itself: Driving to synagogue armed is legal; walking the same route armed on Shabbat can bring a civil fine of up to $500 for a first offense, $750 after that.
- Who's affected: Shapiro, a 29-year-old ordained rabbi and Georgetown law student, carries for the synagogue's volunteer security force because the shul can't staff a paid guard for its full 6 a.m.-to-11 p.m. hours.
- Why walking matters: Observant Jews don't drive on Shabbat, so the "drive-in" allowance is useless to the very congregants the carve-out claims to accommodate.
- Legal argument: Becket senior counsel Eric Baxter, representing the synagogue, told the Forward the arrangement undercuts any safety rationale, since it bars Jews specifically because they must walk on the Sabbath.
- The irony: Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton notes a non-Jewish visitor could legally carry right up to the building's threshold, something Shapiro himself can't manage despite being allowed to carry once inside.
Quick take
This is a clean example of a facially neutral rule producing a religiously discriminatory outcome, and it's worth watching for gun owners generally, not just Orthodox congregations. Any carve-out drawn around a specific mode of travel is going to hit some lawful carriers harder than others, and this case shows how fast that can turn into a First Amendment problem layered on top of a Second Amendment one.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com