Test finds fixed sights beat red dots on speed, not just precision
A new head-to-head test pitting red dot sights against fixed iron sights on carry pistols found that the dot wins on pure precision, but irons held their own or won outright on speed drills closer to realistic self-defense distances.
Snapshot
Writing for Gun Digest, the author ran three shooters of varying red-dot experience through precision and speed drills using a Wilson Combat eXperior Elite set up so only one sight system was available at a time. The red dot sight produced notably tighter groups, but fixed sights matched or beat it on two timed drills built around drawing from the holster and hitting steel.
Key points
- Precision favored the dot: At 10 yards from a rest, groups fired with a Trijicon RMR HD 2 were about 39 percent smaller on average than those fired with fixed sights.
- Step Back Drill was close: Across shots at 5 to 25 yards, fixed sights were faster up close while the red dot pulled ahead only at 25 yards, and total time came out roughly even, with fixed sights about 2 percent faster overall.
- Multi-Target Drill went to irons: All three shooters were faster with fixed sights on a 15-yard, three-target drill, including faster splits, transitions and first shot from the holster.
- Experience matters: The author notes new shooters, including his own daughters, often respond better to red dots, and that highly practiced competitive dot shooters would likely outperform these results.
- No malfunctions reported: Neither sight system produced a single stoppage during testing on the optics-ready pistol used.
Quick take
The author, who carries fixed sights himself, argues the test undercuts the common claim that red dots are automatically better for concealed carry at realistic defensive distances, though he still sees value in a dot for precise shots at 25 yards and beyond. He encourages readers to run their own comparison rather than assume either sight system is the right call for their skill level.
Read the full story: gundigest.com