Courts say a visible holstered gun alone can't justify a police stop
Two state supreme court decisions now say the same thing: a holstered gun printing under your shirt, by itself, is not enough for police to stop you, handcuff you, or search you.
Snapshot
Gun Digest breaks down Hicks v. State of Maryland, a June 2026 en banc ruling, and Indiana's earlier Pinner v. State (2017), both holding that lawful gun possession alone does not create reasonable suspicion for a Terry stop. The courts applied the Supreme Court's 2022 Bruen decision, which treats public carry for self-defense as presumptively lawful, to limit when officers can detain an armed person.
Key points
- The Maryland ruling: Judge Kathryn Graeff wrote that after Bruen, "mere possession of a concealed firearm, by itself, is not indicative of criminal activity," and suppressed evidence from a 2023 Baltimore stop where a detective handcuffed a permit holder over a printing gun.
- Frisks are still allowed: The Hicks court said officers can still frisk an armed person for safety once a stop is otherwise justified, legal carry or not, but going further into pockets or bags without cause crosses the line.
- Indiana set precedent first: In Pinner, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled a bare "man with a gun" report, with no claim of illegality, could not justify detaining someone later found armed in a theater lobby.
- Totality still matters: Both rulings leave room for stops when other facts, like threats, a matching suspect description, or evasive behavior, are added to the presence of a gun.
Quick take
These rulings don't hand carriers immunity from police contact, but they do draw a clearer line against being treated as a suspect for simply exercising a carry right. Gun Digest's advice for carriers, staying calm, keeping hands visible, and asking plainly whether you're being detained, is sound practice regardless of how courts rule.
Read the full story: gundigest.com