Personal Defense

Ten Years Carrying the 5.7x28mm: Separating Myth From Reality

November 17, 2026

A longtime Gun Digest contributor who has carried and reloaded for the FN Five-SeveN MK2 for a decade lays out what the 5.7x28mm cartridge actually does and doesn't do, cutting through years of internet myth about armor penetration and reliability.

Snapshot

The article traces the 5.7x28mm back to NATO PDW trials in the early 2000s and argues that its reputation for defeating body armor is overstated, while its real strengths are light recoil, flat trajectory and solid reliability. The author concludes the cartridge lands between .380 Auto and 9mm Luger in terms of stopping power, and that the Five-SeveN can serve as a workable, if imperfect, self-defense option.

Key points

  • Armor myth: The author writes that NATO testing showed the 5.7x28mm struggles to beat even 0.25-inch mild steel from a handgun barrel, and that the armor-piercing reputation came from trial requirements meant to exclude 9mm Luger, not from real-world carry ammo performance.
  • Ballistics placement: The author places the cartridge's energy close to 9mm Luger and well above .380 Auto, while bullet expansion runs smaller than 9mm, topping out around 0.310 inch with top loads like Speer Gold Dot and Hornady Critical Defense.
  • Coating myth: The polymer case coating, often rumored to be essential to function, made no functional difference in the author's own Five-SeveN MK2 and Ruger-5.7 testing.
  • Design tradeoffs: The Five-SeveN's magazine disconnect safety and lack of optic-mounting options on the MK2 slide are called out by the author as real limitations for a carry gun, despite reliable function across multiple factory loads.
  • Field record: The author reports carrying the pistol for years, mostly in the field and on horseback, with minimal malfunctions across hundreds or thousands of rounds.

Quick take

This is a useful myth-check for anyone curious about the Five-SeveN after it's been in the news, grounded in the author's own decade of handloading and carry experience rather than internet lore. It won't settle the caliber debate, but it gives a fair, specific accounting of where 5.7x28mm actually sits against more familiar carry rounds.

Read the full story: gundigest.com

Gun Rights

Advertise  ·  Press Release  ·  Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact