Why snub revolvers need hard-cast loads, not duty hollow-points
The snubnose revolver has carried a reputation as the thinking carrier's close-range tool for generations, and a new Gun Digest piece argues that reputation still holds up, myths about weak snub ballistics notwithstanding.
Snapshot
The article, written for Gun Digest, looks at why 2-inch .38 Special and .357 Magnum revolvers remain popular despite decades without major design changes. The author argues that online claims about snub performance being "dead" rest on misread gel tests and a poor understanding of how short barrels and bullet construction actually interact.
Key points
- Velocity isn't the problem: the author notes .38 Special can exceed 1,000 fps and .357 Magnum can top 1,200 fps out of a snub, even though full-power .357 loads lose a lot of that speed to the short barrel.
- Expansion is the weak link, not penetration: the piece argues most factory hollow-points are designed around longer barrels and don't reliably expand at snub velocities, so penetration matters more than expansion here.
- Hard-cast bullets get the nod: drawing on Elmer Keith's old bullet designs, the author favors solid, high sectional-density flat-point loads around 800 to 1,100 fps for getting through clothing and barriers.
- Gel testing gets pushback: the author calls most ballistic gel testing "bunk" as a universal standard, since it's built around FBI protocols rather than real tissue behavior.
- .38 +P over full .357: the author says they haven't found a .357 load that performs well from a short barrel, preferring .38 or .38+P even in .357-chambered guns.
Quick take
None of this is a knock on modern defensive ammo in general, it's a specific argument about matching bullet choice to a short revolver barrel. If you carry a J-frame or similar snub, the piece is worth reading before you assume your duty-size hollow-point is doing what you think it's doing out of a 1 7/8-inch barrel.
Read the full story: gundigest.com