Supreme Court Declines All 22 Felon Gun Ban Cases, Leaving Laws Intact
On November 9, the Supreme Court declined to hear 22 Second Amendment cases dealing with prohibited-person gun laws, leaving every one of those laws in place and offering no explanation beyond the denial itself.
Snapshot
According to AmmoLand's review of the Court's orders list, as reported by Bearing Arms, the justices turned away 16 challenges to felon gun bans along with cases on a misdemeanor-DUI prohibition, the federal ban on receiving guns while under indictment, and a lifetime ban tied to a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction. No justice noted a dissent.
Key points
- Felon bans untouched: Cases like Foster v. United States and Barge v. United States, challenging permanent disarmament over nonviolent felonies, were both denied review.
- DUI and indictment laws stand: Holloway v. Brown (Washington's misdemeanor-DUI gun ban) and Trevino v. United States (18 U.S.C. § 922(n), barring gun receipt while under indictment) were also turned away.
- Domestic violence case declined: Minor v. United States asked whether a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction can justify a lifetime gun ban without a specific finding of dangerousness; the Court passed.
- AR-15 cases still moving: The same orders list cleared the Solicitor General to argue alongside gun owners in the December 2 rifle-ban cases, showing the Court isn't avoiding every Second Amendment fight.
Quick take
Tom Knighton of Bearing Arms argues this pattern shows the Court has little appetite for sorting out who can be permanently disarmed, even though it's willing to tackle rifle bans. He notes the Court's own Rahimi ruling already found some people too dangerous for full Second Amendment rights, which may explain why cases like Minor drew no takers. Denial isn't a ruling on the merits, but it keeps every one of these laws exactly where they stood.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com