Summit, N.J.’s Total Gun Shop Ban Sets Up Likely Court Fight
A New Jersey town's push to permanently ban gun shops from every zoning district is heading toward a public hearing, and the lone dissenting council member says it's an invitation to a lawsuit the city could lose.
Snapshot
Summit, New Jersey's Common Council voted 5-1 to advance an ordinance that would prohibit firearms shops citywide, joining detention facilities and AI data centers on the list of land uses council has moved to ban this year. Summit currently has no gun shops, but supporters want to keep it that way through zoning code rather than leave the question open, according to Bearing Arms.
Key points
- Total ban, not relocation: Unlike zoning restrictions in other towns that push gun stores to industrial areas, Summit's measure would bar firearms shops outright in every zoning district, while exempting businesses that sell only accessories like scopes, lights and mounts.
- Council's stated rationale: Councilman Dan Crisafulli said firearms shops pose unique challenges to "neighborhood character, public safety, security, and theft," and argued the ordinance doesn't affect the right to bear arms.
- Dissent warns of legal exposure: Councilman Andrew Smith, an attorney and the sole no vote, said a total ban could be found unconstitutional under current Supreme Court precedent and could cost the city "significant time, money, and resources" to defend.
- Third Circuit precedent looms: Bearing Arms notes the appellate court has already rejected a categorical exception for rules banning commercial firearm sales, calling it untenable under Heller.
- Next step: Residents get to weigh in at the Common Council's December 1 meeting before any final vote.
Quick take
Any town willing to try a flat gun store ban is betting it can find a historical analogue that doesn't exist, and gun owners nationwide should watch how this plays out before similar councils get ideas.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com