Fifth Circuit: Second Amendment Covers Firearm Sales, Not Just Ownership
The Fifth Circuit ruled on November 19 that the Second Amendment's plain text covers firearm sales, a holding that opens federal dealer-licensing restrictions to constitutional scrutiny rather than shielding them as mere commercial regulation.
Snapshot
In United States v. Deare, a three-judge panel vacated a lower court's rejection of a constitutional challenge to federal firearms-dealer licensing and record-keeping requirements, sending the case back to the Western District of Louisiana. The court did not strike down the licensing law itself, but it rejected the idea that firearm sales fall outside Second Amendment review.
Key points
- The core holding: the court stated that the Second Amendment's plain text "covers the sale of firearms," undercutting arguments that commercial firearm regulations automatically escape constitutional review.
- Government concession: federal attorneys reportedly conceded at oral argument that the Second Amendment applies to commercial firearm sales, strengthening the panel's reasoning.
- Judge Ho's concurrence: Judge James Ho compared firearm sellers to booksellers under the First Amendment, arguing rights mean little if the government can restrict the means of exercising them.
- Judge Oldham's concurrence: Judge Andrew Oldham said the remaining question is whether the licensing rules survive the historical-tradition test from Bruen, and criticized an earlier Fifth Circuit precedent, Peterson, as wrongly extended to sales restrictions.
- The dissent: Judge Catharina Haynes argued firearm sellers aren't specifically named in the Second Amendment's text and would have upheld the licensing requirement outright.
Quick take
This is a procedural win, not a knockout. Federal dealer licensing under Section 922(a)(1) remains in force, and Deare's underlying conviction isn't erased. But the binding precedent — that acquiring a firearm is itself Second Amendment conduct — gives Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi gun owners and FFLs a sharper tool for challenging future restrictions on how guns are bought and sold.
Read the full story: ammoland.com