Videos

Why killing a home intruder doesn't guarantee self-defense protection

November 17, 2026

A homeowner shoots an intruder and assumes the case is closed. According to a video from USCCA, that assumption can be wrong, and the legal attorney featured in the video walks through why even a justified-feeling shooting inside your own home doesn't automatically shut the door on a murder charge.

Snapshot

Attorney Damon of the Criminal Law Group explains that self-defense protection hinges on whether a reasonable person would have believed they faced great bodily harm or death. He breaks down the three legal frameworks states use to decide that question, and clarifies that castle doctrine, while powerful, is not a blanket shield against prosecution.

Key points

  • Yes, you can still be charged: Damon says the short answer to facing murder charges after a home-defense shooting is yes, even when the person killed broke into your home.
  • Duty to retreat states: In these states, if escape is reasonably possible before using lethal force, the law expects you to attempt it first.
  • Stand your ground states: Here there's no obligation to retreat; you can hold your position and use lethal force if the reasonable-belief standard is met.
  • Castle doctrine's rebuttable presumption: Damon notes that in castle doctrine states, your home carries a presumption that you reasonably feared great bodily harm, a protection not automatically granted under the other two frameworks.
  • Prosecutors can still rebut it: Damon stresses that presumption isn't absolute. Prosecutors can argue your belief wasn't reasonable, meaning a home shooting is not, in his words, an automatic "get out of jail free card."

Quick take

For gun owners who carry or keep a firearm at home for defense, this is a useful reminder that state law variation matters as much as the facts of the shooting itself. Knowing whether your state leans duty-to-retreat, stand-your-ground, or castle doctrine shapes what prosecutors can and can't presume about your actions.

Watch the full video: USCCA

Gun Rights

Advertise  ·  Press Release  ·  Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact