Videos

Lawyers on self-defense shootings: say less, call your team first

November 17, 2026

What should you actually say in the minutes after a defensive shooting? A panel of self-defense attorneys sat down for a new USCCA Law podcast episode to walk through exactly that, and their answer runs counter to a lot of gut instincts.

Snapshot

In a video from USCCA, attorneys Alan Diamond, Amy Scholes and Dave McDermott discuss the first 90 seconds after a self-defense incident. Their core message: protect the scene, get law enforcement and your attorney involved, and be extremely careful about what you say and to whom, because anything you say can and will be reinterpreted later.

Key points

  • Don't disturb the scene: Alan Diamond says not to move weapons or anything else unless it's unsafe to leave them, since it's now a crime scene.
  • Get your Critical Response Team moving: Diamond and Amy Scholes stress notifying USCCA's CRT right away, or having a trusted family member do it if you can't, so an attorney and bond support are already in motion.
  • Be cautious calling 911 yourself: Dave McDermott says he prefers someone else make that call, since the line is recorded and both the words and your tone can be used against you later.
  • If you must call, keep it short: McDermott advises requesting police and an ambulance to the address, then getting off the line rather than staying on to answer questions.
  • Silence beats a "perfect" statement: Diamond argues no statement can't be spun by a prosecutor, while anything you say, calm or emotional, can be twisted either way depending on the narrative they want.

Quick take

The attorneys frame this as self-protection, not distrust of police, and that distinction is worth sitting with. For concealed carriers who've trained on shooting but not on what comes after, this is the kind of plain-spoken legal walkthrough worth watching in full before you ever need it.

Watch the full video: USCCA

Gun Rights

Advertise  ·  Press Release  ·  Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact