Hickok45 weighs nickel vs. blued finishes on classic revolvers
Nickel-plated revolvers draw plenty of attention at gun shows, but is the shine worth more than looks? In a video from hickok45, the host runs a nickel Schofield through live fire and lays several blued-and-nickel pairs side by side to weigh the pros and cons of the finish.
Snapshot
Hickok45 compares matched pairs of Colt and Schofield revolvers in blue versus nickel to show just how different the two finishes look side by side. He explains that nickel plating was common in the black-powder era for cleanup and corrosion protection, and says his own preference leans toward bluing and color case hardening, though he admits owning and enjoying a handful of nickel guns.
Key points
- History: Hickok45 says nickel plating became popular in the 1870s and 1880s partly because it made cleaning up black powder residue easier.
- Corrosion protection: He notes nickel plating can help protect the underlying metal, though he's seen old nickel guns where the plating has chipped or peeled badly.
- Looks and appeal: He acknowledges some shooters genuinely prefer the shine of nickel or highly polished stainless over blued finishes.
- Wear and care: Hickok45 warns that strong solvents, like Hoppe's No. 9, can damage nickel plating, and that when it wears it tends to flake or blister rather than age gracefully like bluing.
- Tactical downside: He points out that in low light or bright sun, a nickel gun's reflective surface could give away a shooter's position or cause glare that affects aim.
Quick take
Hickok45 isn't arguing nickel is better or worse, just laying out what it actually does for a gun and letting personal taste settle the rest. For anyone eyeing a shiny revolver at a show, his rundown of the real-world upsides and headaches is worth a watch before buying.
Watch the full video: hickok45