Court says DUI alone doesn't justify lifetime federal gun ban
A federal appeals court has drawn a new line on who counts as too dangerous to own a gun, and a drunk-driving conviction alone didn't make the cut.
Snapshot
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit issued two rulings on the federal felon-in-possession gun ban. The court upheld the ban against a man convicted in a 2002 carjacking involving terroristic threats and assault, but struck it down as applied to a man whose only disqualifying conviction was for drunk driving.
Key points
- Carjacking case upheld: James Bost's convictions for terroristic threats, conspiracy, false imprisonment and simple assault were enough to justify disarming him, the court ruled.
- DUI case struck down: A man convicted of DUI in the early 2000s and sentenced to home confinement, won his challenge to the federal gun ban as applied to him.
- Violence is the test: Judge Stephanos Bibas, a Trump appointee, wrote that people can be disarmed when their convictions show a risk of physical violence from misusing guns.
- Dissent on the standard: Judge Arianna Freeman argued the majority's rule is too narrow, saying offenses like drunk driving can still show a "credible threat to the physical safety of others."
- Bigger legal backdrop: The rulings fit into ongoing litigation testing gun laws against the Supreme Court's 2022 Bruen standard, which requires restrictions to match the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Quick take
This is a meaningful split for anyone with an old nonviolent conviction who's been locked out of gun ownership for life. His attorney, Joshua Prince, called it confirmation that there's no historical basis for stripping rights from people whose record doesn't show a threat to others. But Judge Freeman's dissent shows the court isn't unified on where that line sits, so expect more litigation before this settles nationally.
Read the full story: foxnews.com