News

Attorney: Connecticut's AR-15 Ban Brief Misreads Old Weapons Laws

November 18, 2026

A Second Amendment attorney says Connecticut's U.S. Supreme Court brief defending its AR-15 ban leans on medieval and early American laws that don't say what the state claims they say, and the gap matters because the case will likely turn on whether history actually supports banning a commonly owned rifle.

Snapshot

Attorney Alan Beck, who litigated Wolford v. Lopez, reviewed Connecticut's reply brief in the combined Viramontes and Grant cases headed to the Supreme Court. Writing at The Reload, Beck argues the state cites centuries-old English weapons laws, including rules on lancegays, crossbows and handguns, without the context needed to show they were real possession bans.

Key points

  • Old law, thin relevance: Beck notes the Court's Bruen ruling makes it unlikely the justices will lean on English laws centuries removed from the Founding.
  • The lancegay example: Beck says the 1383 law Connecticut cites only barred riding with a lancegay without a royal license, not owning one outright.
  • Checked against historians: Beck told Reload founder Stephen Gutowski he set aside lawyers' and legal academics' readings and consulted actual medieval historians, who suggest lancegays were widely and legally owned.
  • Wills as evidence: Beck points to court-recorded wills bequeathing lancegays as proof the weapon wasn't truly prohibited.
  • Timing: The case is set for oral argument at the Supreme Court on December 2.

Quick take

Beck's digging is a reminder that "historical analogue" arguments in gun cases need real scrutiny, not just a footnote citing an old statute. If his reading holds up, Connecticut's brief leans on laws that regulated how and where weapons could be carried, not whether people could own them, a distinction that matters a great deal for anyone whose AR-15 is on the line.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Gun Rights

Advertise  ·  Press Release  ·  Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact